Fault in City Bus Sideswipe Accident

Mind-Blowing Conclusions: Who Is at Fault in a Sideswipe Accident with a City Bus?


Navigating the bustling streets of any city demands attention and expertise. Amid the chaos of traffic signals, pedestrians, and the urgent hum of engines, city buses serve as the vascular system, carrying people to and from their destinations. However, with their considerable size and limited maneuverability, buses can sometimes become involved in accidents, notably, sideswipe collisions. “Who is at Fault in a Sideswipe Accident with a City Bus?” Determining fault in such incidents isn’t just a matter of pointing fingers; it’s a complex interplay of traffic laws, driver actions, and sometimes, the inherent challenges of urban driving.

In this guide, we delve into the intricacies of assigning liability in serious sideswipe crash accidents with city buses, shedding light on an issue that holds significant ramifications for drivers, passengers, cities, and insurance entities alike. Whether you’re a daily commuter, a bus passenger, or someone who just wants to understand the legal landscape better, this exploration will offer insights into a critical urban safety concern.

What is a Sideswipe Accident?

Who is at Fault in a Sideswipe Accident with a City Bus?

A sideswipe accident occurs when two vehicles traveling in the same or opposite directions make lateral contact with each other, usually involving the sides of the vehicles. Unlike head-on or rear-end collisions, sideswipes typically happen when both vehicles are in motion, parallel to each other. The contact can range from a minor scraping of paint to a more forceful collision that could cause one or both vehicles to lose control.

These sideswipe accidents occur most often occur during lane changes, merges, or when one vehicle drifts out of its lane, possibly due to distracted or aggressive driving. Sideswipes can be especially complicated when they involve larger vehicles like city buses or other cars that have extended lengths, limited visibility, and reduced maneuverability. The nature of a sideswipe collision makes it particularly challenging to determine fault, as both parties may share some degree of responsibility.

How Do Sideswipe Collisions with City Buses Occur?

Sideswipe accidents are a frequent yet often overlooked type of car accident. When these involve city buses, the stakes are higher, involving not just the drivers but potentially numerous passengers as well. The causes of such serious sideswipe car accident accidents are diverse and often complex, making it crucial to consult an experienced car accident attorney to evaluate your sideswipe car accident claim.

Common Causes

  • Changing Lanes Without Attention: One common reason sideswipe accidents occur is when a driver fails to properly check blind spots before changing lanes. This driver error is especially problematic around buses, which have larger blind spots compared to other motor vehicles.

  • Improper Merging: Whether it’s the bus or the other vehicle that’s merging, failure to follow traffic laws can lead to a sideswipe collision.

  • Distracted Driving: Inattention due to phone use, eating, or other distractions can result in a driver, of either the bus or another vehicle, drifting into another lane.

More cars and large vehicles like buses raise the risk of accidents.

Risk Factors

  • High Traffic Volume: More cars on the road increase the likelihood of an accident, particularly when large vehicles like city buses are involved.

  • Aggressive or Reckless Behavior: Speeding, road rage, and abrupt lane changes can escalate the risk of sideswipe car accidents.

  • Environmental Conditions: Weather conditions, poor lighting, or inadequate signage can contribute to sideswipe accidents, complicating the task of determining liability.


  • Medical Expenses and Lost Income: Sideswipe accidents can result in serious to severe injuries requiring emergency room visits, ongoing medical expenses, and potential loss of income.

  • Vehicle and Property Damage: Sideswipe collisions often result in significant vehicle damage for both the bus and the smaller vehicle involved.

  • Insurance Implications: At-fault parties face the risk of rising car insurance premiums, and dealing with insurance companies for claims can be a complex process.

Given the multifaceted nature of sideswipe collisions, documenting the accident scene through traffic cameras, security cameras, medical records, and witness statements is often essential. Police reports and accident reconstruction can also play a role in establishing who the responsible party is in such an accident. Therefore, understanding the common causes and consequences of sideswipe collision can not only help in avoiding such unfortunate incidents but also in navigating the legal and insurance-related aftermath should one occur.

Understanding State and Local Traffic Laws

Navigating the labyrinth of state and local traffic laws is crucial for anyone involved in a motor vehicle accident, including sideswipe collisions with city buses. Understanding these laws not only equips you to follow best practices on the road but can also prove indispensable when determining legal liability or filing a car accident claim. Here are some key aspects to consider:

Basic Traffic Rules:

  • Speed Limits: Knowing and adhering to state and local speed limits is fundamental. Exceeding these limits can jeopardize your claim and place you as the at-fault party.

  • Right of Way: Understanding who has the right of way during merging, lane changes, or at intersections can help in establishing who the responsible party is in an accident.

State-Specific Regulations:

  • Comparative Negligence: Some states, like Florida, operate under a comparative negligence system, which could impact how compensation is recovered if you’re partially at fault.

  • Insurance Requirements: Knowing your state’s car insurance minimums and how they affect your claim can be vital.

Local Bylaws and Ordinances:

  • Bus Lanes: Many cities have specific lanes designated for buses. Failing to respect these lanes could result in fines and potentially place you at fault in an accident.

  • Traffic Signs and Signals: Local governments may also enforce additional rules through traffic signs, such as “No Turn on Red,” which you must follow to avoid liability.

By comprehending the intricacies of state and local traffic laws, you better position yourself not only to avoid accidents oncoming traffic, but also to navigate the complexities of fault and legal responsibilities. This knowledge can be especially beneficial when corroborated with police reports and other evidence to prove or disprove liability in a sideswipe accident with a city bus.

Role of Traffic Cameras and Witnesses

Traffic camera footage can prove liability in court or insurance claims.

In the aftermath of an accident, especially complex ones like a sideswipe collision with a city bus, determining the at-fault party can be a challenging task. This is where traffic cameras and eyewitness accounts play an instrumental role, serving as pivotal pieces of evidence to corroborate narratives and identify responsible parties. Let’s delve into their significance:

Traffic Cameras: A Silent Observer:

  • Objective Footage: Traffic cameras provide an unbiased account of the incident, capturing the events leading up to, during, and after the accident.

  • Vehicle Dynamics: They can clearly depict vehicle speeds, lane changes, turn signal usage, and other driver actions, assisting in accident reconstruction efforts.

  • Legal Evidence: Footage from traffic cameras can be used in court or during insurance claim negotiations to prove liability.

Witnesses: The Human Element:

  • First-hand Account: Witnesses can provide a detailed account of the accident, which can be especially valuable when camera footage is unavailable or inconclusive.

  • Varied Perspectives: Multiple witnesses can offer diverse vantage points, giving a comprehensive understanding of the accident scene.

  • Credibility: An unbiased witness statement can lend significant credibility to a driver’s account, bolstering their case in legal or insurance proceedings.

Harnessing the power of traffic cameras and the testimonies of eyewitnesses can be invaluable in piecing together the puzzle of an accident. Whether it’s to corroborate one’s narrative, dispute the other driver’s version of events, or provide clarity in situations with multiple vehicles, two cars involved or one car, these resources are paramount in determining fault and ensuring justice in the aftermath of a collision.

Who Is at Fault in a Sideswipe Accident with a City Bus?

Liability Considerations Specific to City Buses

If the bus driver sped, was distracted, or didn't signal, they could be liable for the accident.

When it comes to sideswipe accidents involving city buses, the question of liability can be a complex matter with multiple parties potentially at full fault for a sideswipe call. Sorting through the layers of responsibility often requires a nuanced understanding of various scenarios and entities involved. Here are some key considerations:

The Bus Driver: Behind the Wheel Responsibility:

  • Scenarios where the bus driver is at fault: If the bus driver was speeding, engaged in distracted driving, or failed to signal a lane change, they could be held liable for the accident.

  • Driver Training and Qualification: The level of training and expertise the bus driver possesses can also play a role in determining fault.

The Driver of the Other Vehicle: Another Side of the Story:

  • Circumstances under which the other driver could be liable: If the other driver was merging improperly, not paying attention, or violated traffic laws, they may be the at-fault party.

  • Comparative Negligence: In some jurisdictions, both drivers can be partially at fault, affecting the compensation each might receive.

The City or Public Transport Authorities: Institutional Accountability:

  • Cases where the city or transport authorities might hold responsibility: Lack of maintenance, improper training of drivers, or failure to address known safety issues could lead to institutional liability.

  • Regulatory Compliance: If the city or transport authorities fail to comply with safety regulations, this could be a significant factor.

The Bus Manufacturer: The Question of Defects:

  • When and how manufacturing defects could be a factor: Mechanical failures due to manufacturing defects can place the onus of liability on the bus manufacturer.

  • Recalls and Warnings: Previous recalls or warnings related to the bus model in question can also come into play.

Understanding the specific scenarios that relate to each party can greatly assist in pinpointing liability in a sideswipe accident involving a passing car and a city bus. Navigating these complex layers often necessitates legal expertise to ensure that each angle is thoroughly examined and the responsible parties are held accountable.

To find out more about who’s responsible in a sideswiped car accident, click here.

How Comparative Negligence Works in Florida

In the Sunshine State, the concept of comparative negligence plays a significant role in determining liability and compensation in motor vehicle accidents, including sideswipe collisions with city buses. Unlike some jurisdictions that employ a ‘winner-takes-all’ approach recover compensation, Florida’s comparative negligence system allows for a more nuanced allocation of fault. Under this system, each party involved in the sideswipe accident occurs and can be assigned a percentage of responsibility, and any compensation awarded will be adjusted accordingly.

  • Percentage of Fault: After evaluating the circumstances, a court or insurance company may decide that multiple parties share blame. For instance, the bus driver might be found 70% at fault for not checking a blind spot, while the other driver could be 30% responsible for speeding.

  • Adjusted Compensation: If you were to recover $100,000 in damages but were found to be 30% at fault, your award would be reduced to $70,000 in accordance with your share of the liability.

  • Multiple Parties: The principle also extends to scenarios involving multiple parties, where each one’s degree of fault will influence their individual compensation.

Understanding how comparative negligence operates in Florida is crucial when filing a car accident claim or lawsuit. Even if you’re partially at fault, you may still be a liable party eligible to recover some compensation for your damages, be it property damage, medical bills, or lost income. Therefore, it’s advisable to consult an experienced attorney to navigate the complexities of Florida’s comparative negligence laws.

Emergency Situations and Special Circumstances

Fog, rain, or snow can hinder visibility, making it hard for drivers to check surroundings and blind spots.

When discussing sideswipe accidents involving city buses, it’s important to recognize that emergency situations and special circumstances can significantly impact the determination of fault for a serious sideswipe accident call. These unique conditions introduce an additional layer of complexity to already complicated cases. Here are some pivotal elements to consider:

Emergency Vehicles:

  • Right-of-Way: Often, buses and other vehicles must yield the right-of-way to emergency vehicles like ambulances and fire trucks. Failure to do so can shift liability.

  • Unexpected Actions: Emergency vehicles may take sudden, unconventional actions, such as driving against traffic, which can startle other drivers and lead to accidents.

Weather Conditions:

  • Limited Visibility: Fog, rain, or snow can obscure vision, making it difficult for drivers to fully assess their surroundings, including blind spots.

  • Road Slipperiness: Wet or icy conditions can make it challenging for vehicles, especially large ones like buses, to maintain control, thereby increasing the likelihood of a sideswipe.

Understanding the influence of emergency scenarios and special conditions can greatly aid in both preparing a robust legal defense and in seeking rightful compensation. Whether you’re a bus driver, the driver of another vehicle, or a concerned authority, it’s imperative to factor these conditions into your case evaluations and legal strategies.

Legal Aspects

Navigating the legal terrain following a sideswipe accident with a city bus can be complex due to multiple potentially liable parties and varying state laws. Legal guidance is often indispensable for correctly identifying who is at fault in a sideswipe accident with a city bus, negotiating with insurance companies, and if necessary, pursuing a personal injury lawsuit. Here are some focal points to consider:

Why You May Need an Attorney:

  • Complexity of Law: Public transportation involves federal, state, and local laws, which can be difficult to comprehend without legal expertise.

  • Multiple Parties: Identifying the at-fault party—be it the bus driver, the city, or the bus manufacturer—requires a nuanced understanding of the law.

  • Negotiations: Experienced car accident attorneys can negotiate skillfully with insurance companies, potentially winning you a better settlement.

How a Personal Injury Lawsuit Works:

  • Initial Consultation: The first step usually involves consulting an attorney to review the details of the case and to determine if pursuing legal action is viable.

  • Investigation: This includes collecting evidence like traffic camera footage, police reports, and witness statements to build a robust case.

  • Filing a Claim: If an agreeable settlement isn’t reached through negotiations, the next step is filing a lawsuit. Depending on jurisdiction and specifics, this could lead to a trial or a settlement.

Understanding the legal intricacies of a sideswipe accident involving a city bus is crucial for both navigating your immediate responsibilities and protecting your long-term interests. Given the complexity and the stakes involved, legal consultation is not just an option but often a necessity.

Final Thoughts

Determining who is at fault in a sideswipe accident involving other cars and a city bus can be a complex process, given the multitude of factors and parties involved. It’s imperative to recognize that liability may not rest solely on one party; it could be shared between the bus driver, the driver of the other vehicle, the city or transport authorities, the insurance company, and even the bus manufacturer.

Important Key Points:

  • Comparative negligence laws, particularly in states like Florida, can allow for shared liability, affecting the amount of compensation you can recover.

  • Traffic cameras and eyewitnesses play a significant role in establishing the events leading up to and during the accident, thereby influencing the determination of fault.

  • Due to the public nature of city buses, additional layers of bureaucracy and legal requirements can complicate matters. Understanding these complexities is crucial for a successful claim.


  • Always consult with an experienced car accident attorney, especially when dealing with powerful entities like public transportation authorities and their insurance companies.

  • Keep detailed records of the accident, including photographs, eyewitness accounts, and medical bills, to strengthen your case.

How The Law Offices of Jared Spingarn, P.A., A.K.A Hire Jared Can Help

Hiring a specialized car accident lawyer like Jared Spingarn can make all the difference in your case. With expertise in navigating the intricacies of accidents involving public transport and passenger vehicles, The Law Offices of Jared Spingarn, P.A., can:

  • Conduct thorough investigations to ascertain fault, gathering evidence from traffic cameras, eyewitnesses, and even accident reconstruction specialists.

  • Navigate complex insurance negotiations on your behalf, ensuring you receive the compensation you deserve.

  • Expertly guide you through a personal injury lawsuit, if needed, from initiation through to either settlement or trial.

A sideswipe accident with a city bus can have serious injuries and disrupt lives, but with the right legal representation and insurance company, you can navigate through the complexities and uncertainties to find justice and receive due compensation.

Similar Posts